Before reading the justification, I thought the idea was that it would prevent you from eating the whole pint because the spoon is too uncomfy to put up with for more than a few scoops lol

Nope, destroys my enjoyment of the icecream.

The bad spoon drawer is only opened to get out the other things that live there, like the danger circle or the the melon baller or the bad tongs that it's okay to bring to a potluck because you don't care if they make it back to you.

This? This isn't a bad spoon; it's a serving spoon.
Yes, there's a difference. It's the wrong shape and doesn't fit in my mouth.
No, I'm not being picky. You try eating with it!
Oh, you don't want a spoon that big? That is exactly my point, thank you.

Fancy having a whole drawer! Us regular folks only have one drawer for all spoons and we have to pick around for the good ones. Or if you pick a bad one, you throw it into the sink instead of putting it back when you realize. It subsequently sits for a week and a half before getting thrown in the dishwasher. And is then returned cleaner than it was to the drawer as the last time it was returned it had come directly from the sink as you mistakenly thought it was clean. Now, given it is the spoon on top, you are gauranteed to repeat the process again. If only you had another drawer...