Why shouldn't I get a Glock G19 Gen 5? (self.trans_guns)

submitted 5 days ago by compostgoblin to c/trans_guns

8 comments fedilink hide all child comments

I have a 12-gauge Mossberg 500, but I primarily use it for deer hunting with slugs. I want to get a handgun to add to my collection, primarily for self-defense. I don’t plan on concealed carrying at the moment. Glock G19 Gen 5 seems like the way to go, imo, but I’d love to hear any reasons why there might be a better alternative I should look into.

top 8 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old

[-] mean_bean279@lemmy.world 8 points 5 days ago

Have you held a Glock? I hate the saquare shape. Especially if my hands are sweaty/clamy. While I’d like to never have to use my guns against someone in a moment of panic I know my hands would be a bit clammy and any advantage I can have to prevent that would be appreciated. Great guns otherwise.

I personally liked the Sig P226 after holding and shooting a number of 9mm handguns.

For CC the Smith & Wesson Bodyguard is quite nice, but I know you weren’t asking about that. Don’t also be afraid though to look at compact and micro-compact handguns if they fit you better.

[-] SendMePhotos@lemmy.world 9 points 5 days ago

To add on to this, my personal opinion is that the glock angle is weirdly forward. Go to a gun shop. Hold a gun. Point it at an object and THEN check your aim by looking down the sights. Was it where you thought it was? If no, don't buy that gun because it doesn't fit your natural aim. If yes, definitely add that to the "maybe" list.

I held a glock, my natural aim was always lower than the glock itself.

[-] A_Union_of_Kobolds@lemmy.world 3 points 4 days ago

Omg i thought I was the only one who thought they shot weirdly, I chalked it up to inexperience

[-] AngryishHumanoid@lemmy.world 8 points 5 days ago

Have you fired it at a range before? If not you should, it's a perfectly fine handgun but you don't know how it will handle until you try it.

[-] DickFiasco@sh.itjust.works 6 points 5 days ago

If it's going to be a nightstand gun that you don't plan to carry, then you may want to go with a full-size frame like a G17. The extra weight and barrel length will reduce muzzle flip. Either way, try to find a range where you can rent one and try it out.

[-] Samskara@sh.itjust.works 2 points 4 days ago

There are lots of reasons why Glocks are popular handguns. Try it before you buy it to make sure you like it and how it handles.

Good alternatives are Walther PDP Compact and CZ P10c, but there are lots of other 9 mm handguns that are great. It also depends on where you live and what you can get easily and for a good price.

Also explore if you are fine with iron sights or want some nice optics instead.

Where and how do you expect to keep, use, and carry the gun?

Most 9 mm handguns made in the last 40 years are good for self defense. The most important factor is that you actually train handling and shooting your weapon.

[-] Itd4n@ani.social 2 points 5 days ago

FWIW I have this exact model for personal defense and love it.

[-] Marshezezz 2 points 5 days ago

Try it first and see if you like it or not. The firearm of your choice will be very subjective. I love my 19 but you might not enjoy it as much. 17 would be nice too if you aren’t planning on carrying but it’ll be bulky if you end up changing your mind.

this post was submitted on 31 Aug 2025

19 points (100.0% liked)

TransGuns

175 readers

29 users here now

A place for all to discuss defense, weapons, strategy, and related topics, especially in relation to the Igbt community and our allies

The best option for a defensive firearms is a 5.56x45mm AR-15, 12gauge Remington 870 shotgun, and a reputable 9x19mm handgun.

Defensive firearms should have a WML, long guns a sling, and handguns require a Kydex or solid plastic holster that fully covers the trigger.

A red dot or etched optic is ideal, but backup irons are important as well! Be sure to check out r/TheArmedGayAgenda

Check out our Discord!: https://discord.com/invite/HHgsg65CTb

Subreddit Rules

No bullying, harassment, or queerphobia

Any post or comment that is overt or obliquely queerphobic, or otherwise harasses or bullies another user will result in a permanent ban with no opportunity for appeal.

No trolling

Obvious trolling will not be tolerated. This includes comments or posts that are concern trolling or sea lioning. Mod discretion will be used to determine

Do not spread misinformation

Do not knowingly spread misinformation. You can be sure your information is accurate when you are able to find multiple unbiased sources that agree with what you're saying.

Provide details about your post

All posts containing a picture of a firearm must include details on the make and model of the gun(s) and any add-on parts like optics. If the firearm is built from parts, please include details on these parts. At a minimum whether or not they are off the shelf parts.

On posts asking for suggestions

If you are requesting information or suggestions on a product your post must include what your intended use for the product is, and your budget. Especially for requests for input on a first gun.

Promotions, shills, journalists, and surveys

Linking to products, retailers, promotional advertisements, organizations, etc. will not be allowed if you are in anyway affiliated. If you would like to promote your non-profit or other organization, you must message the mods before posting. This includes journalists seeking to interview users. Please do not DM community members without first contacting the mods through the mod mail.

Remain Civil

Criticism should be constructive, and related only to the topic in the post you're commenting on, no unsolicited advice. Be open minded to receiving criticism. infighting and slap fights will not be tolerated.

Keep NSFW posts to Spank Bank Sunday

Please keep all NSFW posts to Sundays, using the NSFW tag.

All Spank Bank Sunday posts should remain free of pornography, genitals, and nipples.

Posts containing similar content for the purpose of education (e.g. ccw advice) are allowed any day of the week.

Mods will use our discretion in removing posts that break this rule.

founded 6 months ago

MODERATORS

Teknevra