26
Recommendation for systemd free security focused distro
(programming.dev)
OpenBSD
Open BSD, except it doesn't support flat pack. But it's everything else you want
But, I wouldn't recommend using it as a desktop. If you want real security and isolation, look at qubes for your desktop.
Qubes uses xen, a real microkernel, as the hypervisor, which reduces the risk surface of VM escapes tremendously, then you run your untrusted services in their own vms.
Why not systemd? You seem to want futuristic and secure things like Wayland and flatpak, yet don't want the security benefits of systemd?
Will we ever get to the point where we are too tired to explain why we hate systemd, and the point where we get respect for deciding to not use systemd? To me it's about the same level of asking me "why be a lesbian" now.
"Ok grandpa let's get you to bed"
Probably because of its compliance with age verification standardization.
You mean the change that was writen as an act of malicious compliance, by someone opposed to age verification laws, in such a way as to make an easy end run around them for all Linux developers, but then everyone went off half-cocked and started sending the author death threats? That compliance?
Dominik sees practical, non-surveillance uses for the field, like tailoring workshop laptops to age-appropriate defaults without restricting access to anything.
No one deserves death threats, but per the quote above, the existence of the setting still encourages distributions to ask for the user's age at setup, as apps may require the setting to be enabled to know how to handle the user's data and which experience is best suited for them.
While this may automate the parental control process for parents, many users don't want their data used by software in ways they don't consent to, even if it doesn't leave the device.
Thats kinda the point of the malicious compliance though. It’s an optional field. By default, distros can choose to ignore it or auto fill in 1900-01-01. In places where it’s required by law, adduser can ask and it will accept anything. The same way adduser currently asks for your real name, phone numbers, and room number but does not give a fuck what they are or if you fill them out.
The parental controls issue is actually a bigger deal. I would love to give my kids a Linux laptop that could actually protect their privacy while also giving me good parental control tool, but such a thing does not exists. Yes, if you do a quick search for “Linux parental controls” you’ll find some things, but they are clearly half-assed attempts that don’t really work. This absolutely doesn’t either but maybe it’s a step in that direction. Instead, I do what most schools and parents do and give them a Chromebook because it has a good, though not great, parental control system.
Let me be clear, I am also opposed to age verification laws and have written, called and had meetings with my representatives to oppose them. It’s been somewhat successful, though not as much as I would like.
In the end, malicious compliance that allows FOSS developers plausible deniability is better than ignoring the laws and hoping that you’re not the one they decide to make an example of.
Artix is great if you don't mind Arch. Devuan is great if you like lightweight Debian (server install). MXLinux is nice if you want Debian with a usability/UI focus. As for security focused, I don't know what that means. A machine is either secure or it's not. Chuck SELinux on there if it helps you sleep at night.
hardened
This is an important keyword but perhaps not sufficiently discussed. I'd reckon focusing on it will be pretty helpful.
So..., what is it you want? Is it
- A. Make a fortress out of a very decent starting point? To daily drive it afterwards*.
- Or B. Daily drive a fortress built by someone else?
- Or perhaps even C. Something else entirely?
By the rest of your post, I'd bet on B. Which, puts us into an interesting situation...
systemd free
Assuming^[To be honest, I don't see any reason to not grant them the benefit of doubt. As far as I can tell, their lists look complete.] DistroWatch does a decent job at tagging/categorizing, there are only a handful of distros that are both systemd-free and tagged with "security". Note that half of these don't survive it upon closer inspection, which leaves us with Alpine, HardenedBSD and OpenBSD.
If you're well-versed into hardened distros, you'll note the absence of Linux' finest in this category; namely Kicksecure and secureblue. Their absence is due to their (heavy) reliance on systemd for additional hardening.
Furthermore, note that DistroWatch doesn't mention how well the likes of Artix, Gentoo and Void (among others) would function as excellent starting points to build your own fortress from.
Wtf so you mean Alpine will not work on real hardware on desktop? I run Alpine on real hardware for a desktop. The only issue you'll run into is video games not playing nicely with musl, but there's compatibility layers you can use for that.
Void works fine with Wayland. It isn't security-focused. Same goes for Artix.
OpenBSD is security-focused, but has limited Wayland support. Sway works on it, but there isn't much Wayland software, and it's missing some crucial things like xdg-desktop-portal.
Gentoo might be what you're looking for.
I'm using artix with cosmic desktop. It's light enough for my 15 year old laptop. I haven't tried it yet, but Chimera Linux seems to fit what you're looking for.
this post was submitted on 16 Aug 2026
26 points (100.0% liked)
Linux
18721 readers
128 users here now
Welcome to c/linux!
Welcome to our thriving Linux community! Whether you're a seasoned Linux enthusiast or just starting your journey, we're excited to have you here. Explore, learn, and collaborate with like-minded individuals who share a passion for open-source software and the endless possibilities it offers. Together, let's dive into the world of Linux and embrace the power of freedom, customization, and innovation. Enjoy your stay and feel free to join the vibrant discussions that await you!
Rules:
-
Stay on topic: Posts and discussions should be related to Linux, open source software, and related technologies.
-
Be respectful: Treat fellow community members with respect and courtesy.
-
Quality over quantity: Share informative and thought-provoking content.
-
No spam or self-promotion: Avoid excessive self-promotion or spamming.
-
No NSFW adult content
-
Follow general lemmy guidelines.
founded 3 years ago
MODERATORS