We don’t
Everyone is saying "we don't," but do need a diet that's more varied than cats? (for example) If so, why?
Survival =/= nutrition
I'm a living proof that you can eat the same thing every day for decades and be just fine.
If the food you're eating doesn't contain all the nutrients you need you're unhealthy as fuck and it will come back to haunt you.
To add on to other peoples answers regarding the complete nutritional makeup of pet food; many animals can make a variety of the amino acids they need to survive with just a few inputs (like deer and cows eating only (mostly) plants), but some, especially predatory animals, cannot. They get those nutrients from the prey they eat, which in turn got them from the plants.
It essentially comes down to which enzymes any given organism can create, which ones their DNA codes for. Humans can't make a bunch of these amino acids themselves. Many (maybe all of them, not that far into my class yet) of the reactions taking in place in any living organism are entirely reliant on enzymes to catalyze them; that is, without them these reactions would take millions of years to complete.
BTW there are appr. 37x10^17^ (3,700,000,000,000,000,000) reactions happening in your body every second. All of them (or at least a great majority of them) require enzymes to complete.
We don't. Burritos exist.
Damn you. Another new white t-shirt with coffee and snot stains. Take my upvote.
need a variety of food to survive?
It's not true.
Boredom feels terrible while it lasts, but it doesn't kill you. In the end, humans usually start to get creative after boredom.
Oh, and yes, some food industry has found out things and told you things... yes, they were creative :-)
What about the British? They were starving, and they didn't get creative. They just kept eating brown goo for centuries.
I like British food. I live in Germany now and if I see another Maultasche I'm going to scream.
We like carbs which are often brown and make for a good hangover food. Not sure about goo though?
I had heard that British cuisine was much more robust before WW1.
Also, if brown goo is meat-flavored, I'd be down for it.
Got a recipe book for the British working class that was written in the 1800s, even that has curry in it.
It is brown goo flavored, and you will eat it until you are completely brainwashed into liking it.
I suppose that's why we added mild pain to our diet. Mix things up a bit.
Asked my GF who's an aspiring crazy cat lady:
It's because (proper) cat food is engineered to contain all the nutrients they need. While it looks like a bland mush of only one thing, it's more like the cat equivalent of having several full nutricious meals run through a blender. The required variety is built in.
I’m convinced you could create such a food for humans too, it’s just not many people want that.
Isn't that basically what Huel is?
Speak for yourself, bachelor chow would solve many problems for me

Awww shieeet I JUST got done finding a pee'n'gee. What am I gonna do with this thing now?

I’m convinced you could create such a food for humans too,
You could, and it would be very simple to do so.
1: Take all the food you'd eat for, say, a week. Absolutely everything.
2: Blend it. Maybe add some extra vitamins to make up for the ones that will be lost due to processing.
3: Dehydrate it. (To make it more compact and less likely to spoil.)
4: Compress it into pellets.
Done. You have now created 'human food'.
Blending it is pre-digesting it which means it doesn’t travel our bodies quite the same way.
We have long digestive systems for a reason.
I’m not saying it isn’t possible but you’d probably shit funny for a long time
Pemmican! We should be eating pemmican.
That’s what I find so absurd about the “humans need variety in their diet” mantra. If we need some vast unknown combination of things, how is it that letting people loose on supermarkets and choosing their own recipes somehow achieves that, compared to at least some first pass attempt based on macro nutrients?
Because many of our modern staples are fortified with essential vitamins and nutrients.
We also get cravings for specific foods when our bodies are lacking in a nutrient that food contains. I don't think we have them for every nutrient our bodies need, hence why people can get nutrient deficiencies by accident even when the nutrient they need is available, but there's some instinctual failsafes for certain ones that must have been scarce or intermittent enough for cravings to confer an evolutionary advantage.
Ok, what we'll do is, we'll take some sort of kibble, A, fortify it, call it "Vegetable Delight". Then another sort of kibble, B, fortify that, call it "Ox Fondue". Then another, just like the previous ones, call it, say, "Mystery Surprise". All fortified. Then you just alternate them. Mondays, A. Tuesdays, B. Then Wednesdays you think C but nope! A again. Then B, then A, THEN B, and then, finally C, so you have something special to look forward to on Sundays.
There are powdered meals that are supposed to offer balanced nutrition. I've heard of people living off Soylent, Huel, etc. I don't think it's good long-term, and the lack of chewing could cause problems. But it is feasible in principle.
I ate only soylent for a long time, and the lack of chewing did cause me some issues: first was bad oral hygiene. I brush and floss twice a day (after breakfast and before bed), yet I still got a cavity. Chewing normal food also cleans off plaques on your teeth, so when you're not chewing anything those plaques just sit there fucking your shit up. Second (*and this is just my conjecture) chewing causes activity in a certain part of the brain to spike, so if you're not chewing anything that part atrophies and causes depression. I forget where I read the chewing part though. So, along with the cavity, I also felt generally sad about everything. I would still definitely have it for lunch everyday because the nutrients are there, but yeah, unfortunately you have to chew stuff. I thought about just chewing gum, but those are all chock-full of microplastics so...
lack of chewing
this is also a solved issue with a mature industry
That's true, but we're not cats.
It's can be difficult to change a cat's food. You have to gradually introduce the new food mixed in with the old food, or the cat may just refuse to eat it.
Oh ho ho ho. They will eat. Eventually. Then they get more. Then they complain it's not enough.
They have.
You as a human could also live with the same food every day if it covered every dietary need. Especially if you depended on someone else to acquire it and had no choice.
There is an evolutionary push for a rich variety of nutrients obtained from a variety of sources, but the mechanism driving that daily "need" for variety is force of habit and desire for novelty. On top of that, some people are happy to eat nothing but junk and have very narrow tastes. How come?
Also, I can assure you, a lot of cats will periodically stop eating a certain brand or flavor and go through cycles. Does it mean the food isn't really covering their needs or are they just bored of the same flavor every day? Hard to know, but I would argue your assumption about humans being too different from their pets when it comes to variety in their menu.
Cats and similar animals are adapted to specific environmental niches, but humans are generalists. One of the drawbacks of being generalists is that we’re not specialized enough to fully subsist on any single food source.
We can definitely subsist on a single food source if it's been engineered to be nutritionally complete like pet food has.
We don't need a variety of food to survive. But, generally, we have choice, so we choose to vary our diet because it's more interesting.
Pets do not have a choice. They eat what they're given. Or they choose not to and die (a lil cat I was sitting chose that route).
They eat what they’re given. Or they choose not to and die (a lil cat I was sitting chose that route).
What the fuck? Cats don't just chose not to eat and die. That cat died from neglect.
I was under the impression cats fed on sunlight and heat? I thought the food was just like, a scheme to drain the household economy.
He was well fed and offered different foods. His owners played with him and kept him clean. He didn't want to eat. They had him tested for allergies, etc but the vet didn't find anything wrong. They put him on something to increase his appetite. He ate a little. Then he stopped.
Wildcats (tigers, lions, bobcats, etc) will take down a prey animal. We think they just eat the muscle. In reality, they often go for the stomach of the herbivore they just brought down to get the vegetable matter there. Then they eat other internal organs (liver, spleen, kidneys) so they aren't just eating muscle.
For our pets, well, we all know they don't eat the same thing every day. Firstly, the the thing they do eat every day, pet food, has various nutrients included so it's a balanced meal for them. Secondly, we give them treats which may or may not be beneficial.
As for we humans wanting variety, it's exactly that. We want but don't need as much variety as we get. We enjoy the different flavors even if the items containing those flavors aren't exactly good for us (twinkies, 8 year scotch, etc). Our pets and wild carnivores don't get the opportunity to try these other flavors (well, our pets get some opportunity but not to the extent we have granted ourselves).
There's that tech bro that has a super strict diet for longevity. Its basically enough protein for him and veg, fruit to fill out the rest of his calorie goal along with some supplements. I wanna say Bryan or Ryan Johnson. its basically same everyday with a workout plan to live as long as he can.
If you think about it, for the past hundreds of thousands of years we've been regionally locked in our areas so variety is a loose term.
I have a low burnout rate with food, and there are probably meals that I could just keep eating repeatedly. Note that these are multi-ingredient foods so could theoretically offer balanced nutrition and be flavored to a preferred taste.
I don't do so for several reasons: cost, availability, convenience, sharing meals with others who have different food preferences, and simply because I still prefer variety.
Kongbap says nah, it's all you need to survive.
Not sure that's a universal thing with cats. Unless she's really hungry, the current feline resident of my household most definitely will turn her nose up at a dish if it's the same as she was fed in the last meal.
Ask Lemmy
A Fediverse community for open-ended, thought provoking questions
Rules: (interactive)
1) Be nice and; have fun
Doxxing, trolling, sealioning, racism, and toxicity are not welcomed in AskLemmy. Remember what your mother said: if you can't say something nice, don't say anything at all. In addition, the site-wide Lemmy.world terms of service also apply here. Please familiarize yourself with them
2) All posts must end with a '?'
This is sort of like Jeopardy. Please phrase all post titles in the form of a proper question ending with ?
3) No spam
Please do not flood the community with nonsense. Actual suspected spammers will be banned on site. No astroturfing.
4) NSFW is okay, within reason
Just remember to tag posts with either a content warning or a [NSFW] tag. Overtly sexual posts are not allowed, please direct them to either !asklemmyafterdark@lemmy.world or !asklemmynsfw@lemmynsfw.com.
NSFW comments should be restricted to posts tagged [NSFW].
5) This is not a support community.
It is not a place for 'how do I?', type questions.
If you have any questions regarding the site itself or would like to report a community, please direct them to Lemmy.world Support or email info@lemmy.world. For other questions check our partnered communities list, or use the search function.
6) No US Politics.
Please don't post about current US Politics. If you need to do this, try !politicaldiscussion@lemmy.world or !askusa@discuss.online
Reminder: The terms of service apply here too.
Partnered Communities:
Logo design credit goes to: tubbadu