1. Bad Tolkien adaptation.
2. Middling fantasy drama with wildly uneven pacing and poor character development.

Meandering and unevenly paced. Some of it was extremely boring.

Visually, it was stunning, but that hardly mattered when half of it was obstructed by your eyelids because you kept falling asleep.

Skip all of the hobbit stuff until they meet the stranger, and then skip all of the rest of the hobbit stuff until the last episode because absolutely none of the rest of it matters.

It was entertaining.

Visually it was good. The plot was boring and super slow. It was several hours of buildup and then things finally started to happen... for ~10 minutes before it ended. The whole first season should have been told in 2 hours or less.

I would only be able to watch it again if it were playing in the background and my focus was elsewhere.

It was ok.

Badly acted. Doesn't really go anywhere.

Depends on how TikTok-brained you are. I think it's way too slow for many people these days, but if you can still enjoy slower paced entertainment, it's great.

I couldn’t make it through one episode. It was just so dull.

Regrettably rather disappointing.

It wasn't perfect, but definitely not bad. Specially the first season finishes on an amazing high note that made me go "dammit, I want more now".