298
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 18 Apr 2026
298 points (100.0% liked)
Fediverse
41720 readers
217 users here now
A community to talk about the Fediverse and all it's related services using ActivityPub (Mastodon, Lemmy, Mbin, etc).
If you wanted to get help with moderating your own community then head over to !moderators@lemmy.world!
Rules
- Posts must be on topic.
- Be respectful of others.
- Cite the sources used for graphs and other statistics.
- Follow the general Lemmy.world rules.
Learn more at these websites: Join The Fediverse Wiki, Fediverse.info, Wikipedia Page, The Federation Info (Stats), FediDB (Stats), Sub Rehab (Reddit Migration)
founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS
I've never heard of Hexbear. Care to explain?
Many instances defederated from them because a large chunk of the user base was abusive and brigading. To an extent even the worst right wing instances federated couldn't match.
Lemmy.world defederated from hexbear "pre-emptively" before they even had federation active. To this day, I have never seen this mythical hexbear brigading.
Yes. And people including myself have accounts on other servers. And experienced it personally 3-4 years ago. That you didn't experience it doesn't disprove it. There's a reason many of us chose servers like world as primary, that didn't federate.
It's more often the reverse. You'll see accounts in hexbear-adjacent servers posting "Why Stalin Was Worse Than Hitler" tier content, getting banned, and then coming over to .world to scream and cry about how they've been censored by the mean Tankies.
[source needed]
I don't like tankies much either but I've seen way worse from the fascists.
I saw right wingers raging (rarely), but there would be a post about Bernie sanders and every time there's a hexbear user saying "this capitalist bootlicking swine, I never want to see his revolting war criminal face again." And replied to all comments saying "wtf is wrong with you" with similar comments. Go check the thread of my instance asking if we should defederate, I can find it if you want. So many people who said "the toxicity from hexbear is overwhelming," myself included.
I don't disagree with you. I think that we should encourage the hexbears to be pitted against the great danger first - fascism. When I discuss factionalism and solidarity, I try to put the accent on "I understand your criticism, and that is why we should focus on the great danger: fascism and corporatism. If we will grow without compromising, we must rally all behind that cause, so that we foster solidarity."
Propaganda at its core, is "sling something at the wall often enough and it becomes truth".
To be fair, they did specify right-wing Lemmy instances, not right-wingers in general, and I can't think of any instances that would meet that definition off the top of my head.
But Hexbear definitely has a reputation as some of the worst of the worst of the normal instances. Blahaj defederated from them despite Ada trying to get the trans communities of both instances connected because of the harassment, brigading, and outright transphobia Hexbear inflicted on Blahaj users for not being the right kind of leftists. You can still find the community discussions on the topic in the general instance posts. They even tried to claim that Blahaj was being transphobic to them. You know, the LGBTQ instance created and ran to be a space for trans people and others first and foremost.
Hexbear is also known to have at least once tried to convince their mods to "take over other instances and ban all the non-communists."
I believe that at this point if you were to download the stuff to spin up your own instance, Hexbear is on the list of instances that are defederated by default because so many instances have defederated them because of their behavior.
Not really sure if it's useful to ask if diarrea or regular shit is worse.
I don't want to step in either
Well, for one, in eg. East Germany, homosexuality was decriminalised before in the West.
In fascist Italy and Germany, you were sent to a concentration camp.
And women's rights, and public infrastructure, and access to education etc.
True. That's what the east reserved for people who critizised the state
There were no concentration camps in the Eastern Block, though, the word you're looking for is "prison", which exists in all societies (mostly in the US though).
As for criticising the state, you couldn't publicly criticise the party leader or the communist model in public without getting in trouble (no jail for just talking though), but as they say "in communism you couldn't criticise one person (the party leader), in capitalism you can't criticise your boss or your company".
I'd like to thank you for proving my point
Ultimately that comes down to personal experience and circumstance. And as you can see a lot of people either experienced it themselves or saw it as well. And I don't think it's controversial to say that the Chapo Trap House crew are rather immature. Unfortunately for you a lot of the evidence that you're searching for is lost to time on instances that were Federated that have shut down. If you have access to hexbear you could probably find some of them I'm sure lurking around from 3 to 4 years ago.
Not going to lie I haven't interacted with them in at least 3 years and I haven't missed it. Maybe they've matured. Anything is possible.
Not disputing your claim, as it doesn't surprise me at all, but I'm curious: What are "the worst right wing instances" ?
I haven't paid enough attention to notice any instances with a consistent and noticeable right-wing lean.
There used to be exploding-heads.com, it was right-wing but not particularly active IIRC
Seconded, I am curious, too. I've only seen Tankies, Democrats, and Anarchists in lemmy.world, I haven't come across one Trump supporter in months.
They are authoritarian left and even though Russia is not a leftist country they will refuse to say a single thing bad about Russia, China, and some will even say nothing is wrong with north Korea. If you search the instance for 'Ukraine' you will see them saying Russia is the good guy in the Ukrainian war. They will say things like authoritarianism doesn't actually exist. I legitimately wonder how many posts are state sponsored lol. There are a lot of them on lemmy.ml as well
Just a week ago I had a conversation with someone that is thinking that Russia is a still a communist country and was arguing if I was sure about the opposite
Oh? What authority do they posses?
https://hexbear.net/search?q=Ukraine&type=All&listingType=All&page=1&sort=TopAll&titleOnly=false
shrug
Come see for yourself. I did.
hexbear.net is an explicitly and unapologetically instance of Lemmy. They're known for their active userbase, light trigger on banning Zionist, transphobic or even pro-western content (which angers many people who live in the west), and their love for beanis
You guys are so weird. Russia is awful for non-cis people and you're all falling over yourselves simping for them.
Nobody simps for Russia over in Hexbear, internal policy is terrible, but the fact is that it's been forced by the west to adopt many anti-imperialist policies, which communists are right to offer CRITICAL support
Got it. Everything is the west's fault. Very nuanced.
Not everything, but as things stand, most things yeah. It's what happens when you concentrate power for 100 years in one or two capitalist nations.
To you, "nuance" simply means "other nations must be even worse, look, I saw it on my western disinformation"
You're the one who keeps dick measuring countries. I call out specific bad actions, regardless of who commits them.
It's okay though, the west made you post that message.
I'm not "dick measuring" countries, you just systematically perform western-biased analysis of what are good and what are bad actions. For instance, you'd criticise the Chinese internet firewall or the Russian support to Assad, when the realistic alternatives are measurably worse. It seems that "lesser evil" to you guys is something that only applies to western genocidal maniacs and not to actually significantly different nations.
I wasn't thinking about the Chinese internet firewall at the moment, but you bring up a good point - that's a bad thing. What's the alternative, internet freedom where china can't police the media and public discourse?
Sucks how the west makes china censor it's citizens.
The alternative is "free speech" dominated by western tech oligarchs in platforms subjected to intelligence monitoring and constant western interference. It's exactly these things leading to murderers like Bolsonaro and Milei being elected.
So the state should choose what people can read and say?
Why on earth would you want that?
I really don't get the tankie obsession with dictators and authoritarian rule. It seems so contrary to socialist ethos.
The state already chooses what people can read or say. I live in the EU, all Russian media are banned here. I fundamentally don't disagree with banning Russian media, but it proves that this already happens, it's just that the state sees that generally western media dominate internationally and it allows us to read it.
In the context of China, if the alternatives are between banning western media and not banning it, the success of the Chinese model and its resilience against western intelligence and propaganda make it obvious to me that the firewall was the correct choice in retrospect, however unsavory it may seem from the outside.
Since you're so excited about being exposed to all media: do you personally go out of your way to watch Russian, Chinese, Cuban or Iranian media and engage with their citizens online, or does your "media freedom" de-facto result in you exclusively consuming western sources?
There's the obvious language barrier, but just because something is not from the west does not mean it's accurate.
I lived in Hong Kong for 3 years, Malaysia for 1, and live in a former Soviet country, so I am no stranger to non-western options.
I hope you give non-western media the same critical analysis that you do western media.
I'm not okay with suppression of information though. How would I even interact with Iranian citizens given that the government has blocked internet access?
Media isn't blocked in western countries like it is in authoritarian dictatorships like china, Russia, Iran, north Korea, Cuba, etc...
Lack of popularity does not equal censorship and that's a huge distinction. If I wanted to, I could read NK news.
it's just a leftist lemmy instance
It's a leftist instance that's very active and will argue with people that post anticommunist popaganda.