Looks like the sources are different: In the top right of the response you can see the fav icons of the sites the AI used to get info. They are ~~apparently the same three pages, but in a different order~~ different pages, and in the OP it says +5 vs +3 in the other screenshot.

So it looks like they might have dropped a couple of bad sources somewhere along the way. But that doesn’t help those who already got bad answers in the meantime..