Thanks for the post OP, updating my VaultWarden docker instance ASAP.

It’s achievable by any frequency supported by Meshtastic. The average range you can expect, with good LoS, is between that 5-10km range.

However, if you have different circumstances you can expect less or even far above the average.

https://meshtastic.org/docs/overview/range-tests/

The range test article above shows the current record for a successful ping/chirp to another node (Point to Point, no additional hops). It’s at 254km currently :)

If that’s the only gripe you have, then it just seems like you’re looking for reasons to not use this technology.

That’s okay, it’s not for everyone. If you prefer to use your HAM radio, by all means feel free to do so and occupy those frequencies.

Myself and others in the Meshtastic community will still welcome you with open arms, if and when you decide to check it out.

Very low cost of entry ($30-40), mesh capability for redundancy, and its on fairly accessible public bands although it occupies a specific part of it. Also it comes with end to end encryption.

It’s just a far more cost effective solution compared to having a CB radio, where you’d need to be licensed to have certain features or to communicate on VHF/UHF etc. You also wouldn’t need to learn any sort of HAM based etiquette to operate these devices.

Although if you need the extra capability, like voice comms, and want the flexibility that comes with HAM you can also incorporate these into that system.

Yeah, I personally have a handful of nodes scattered around my local area.

They’re mostly situated with family, so it’s become a sort of adhoc emergency comms network if a hurricane or other natural disaster causes issues for me locally.

The two points I can agree with here are redirecting traffic to their website and the lack of some context before doing so.

I don’t have an issue with OP posting about this frequently, but to be fair if you’re doing it to farm traffic to your own website with the most minimal effort involved possible then it becomes an issue.

OP should definitely at least put some effort into this going forward.

You wouldn’t need internet access for these to work, although there is a public community WAN server you could join to operate under MQTT (which is their internet facing WAN function). They function off of LoRa RF on the 915mhz band in the U.S. (and other bands elsewhere) to do the bulk of the communication. BLE is also utilized for management.

These do need more than 1 node to operate properly, but since it works off the concept of a public mesh (with options to privatize), you don’t need two of your own devices in a developed location.

However, if no one is around or within line of sight… then you’ll have to work a little harder to get contacts/connections going.

Is there a set “tipping point” in this community? Or are we back to arbitrary rules like Reddit?

It’s technology related and OP is eager to share, again you really don’t have to click on the link or look at this post if it bothers you.

Add another casualty to the list:

https://killedbygoogle.com/

I don’t understand your comment. This IS technology, thus it’s perfectly fine to post here. You don’t need to click on it or view it.

And I can appreciate OP wanting to share a new concept or idea, or promoting this project further as it’s interesting imo.

Lol, I still remember this scene. Damn, super troopers was such a good movie, still is.

These extremists don’t care about international law, or established laws. Apparently the only laws they respect anymore are the one they make themselves.