I can say that my Q2 has been a joy to use. Every issue I've had with it so far has been user error. (Polymaker recommends no fans on their ASA. No, the ASA yearns for the fans, at least when your chamber is heated.)
And if you're posting here, you probably want the option to print with high end engineering filaments. The P1S "can" print PA6CF, but you're gonna need to upgrade it. And if you want to run something like PPACF? Gonna need even more mods.
The Q2 handles everything short of PEEK/PEI like a champ right out of the box.
But the Q2 is a brand new printer released three months ago, so don't expect it to go on a good discount any time soon. But honestly, $650 isn't a bad price for what you get. So yeah, I'd say go for the Q2 if you're posting here. The Q2 is probably dollar for dollar the best guncad printer around.
Note: I can't speak to how good the Box/Qidi AMS is. Because I ordered the Q2 Combo on week 1 and they still haven't sent my box yet, apparently because they just released a new revision that fixes the big pain points of the design and they're shipping that out instead of the v1.0 Box.
Supposedly some sort of people asking for STLs situation caused it this time.
But honestly, I think the real reason is that Reddit doesn't want 3d2a anywhere on their site. It's the only reason I can think of why they keep banning 3d2a subs for "rule 7 violations" when all of the subs are very clear that anyone who asks for files will get banned. If reddit was operating in good faith they'd allow the sub mods to follow their own rules and issue bans before leaping to nuking the whole community.