83
They are trying to convince the Albertans they are gonna walk away with over half of the pension fund... which will never, ever happen. Ever.
Ever.
I tend to think it was a misstep on Smith's part to make the report they funded so overwhelmingly positive for them. Even those who would be on the winning side of it have to be thinking it's too good to be true. Polling seems to back that up.
Even if it did, it'll be handed over to O&G before the end of their term anyway.
How the heck is this even supposed to work with cross province migration? I migrated from BC having paid the full amount into the CPP for many years and now Alberta gets to pay claim to it? What if I move after they seperate, two meager pensions? What a mess.
Quebec has had its own pension plan for a long time. I expect should we go through with this, it'd be a similar mechanism to however they handle it.
Still a terrible idea though, because the UCP literally can not do math, or successfully manage finances.
But, the idea isn't unique, Quebec already did it... And the fact that the UCP isn't pointing that out as justification to me speaks volumes about the political hatred for Quebec by the Albertan right wing.
From what I read Quebec didn't leave though. They just never joined
I guess you could maybe just let all albertans who have retired take from the cpp going forward from the start date, then everyone after that just contributed to app, but that will take like 45+ years to fully switch over and need to deal with the overlap somehow throughout that time.
If you do that so that anyone born after 2004 or whatever only contributes to app it's not gonna be fair to them when the app goes bankrupt
It works "fine" for QPP, so I assume it would be the same for APP. Out of all the very valid concerns over this plan, inter-provincial migration isn't really one of them.
Also worth noting that as a remote employee of QC from SK, I find myself paying into both QPP and CPP now, reducing my expected takehome overall.
AFAIK, it should just be QPP deductions. Either way, your over-contributions should be sorted out at tax time.
Yeah you for sure are only supposed to be paying one. I worked from AB for a QC based company for a few years.
Yes, it's not like the oil and gas companies are going to give back all that money after Danielle Smith gives it to them. They aren't even paying to clean up their own messes when they've squeezed every possible dollar out of the province and leave.
Nope. It all goes to their overpaid executives. Somebody has to pay for their private jets and multiple residences on Kauai.
I hate it here
Those crazy Albertans.
Does anyone have the original Trudeau letter? I can't find it
This was surprisingly bothersome to dig up, but I was able to find it: https://twitter.com/BryanPassifiume/status/1714637930977767619
Thanks! I can't believe how hard it was to find!
this post was submitted on 22 Oct 2023
83 points (100.0% liked)
CanadaPolitics
1875 readers
14 users here now
Placeholder for any r/CanadaPolitics refugees
Rules:
All of Lemmy.ca's rules apply
- No bigotry - including racism, sexism, ableism, homophobia, transphobia, or xenophobia.
- Be respectful. Everyone should feel welcome here.
- No porn.
- No Ads / Spamming.
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS