Q is the DM ? Janeway, Picard, Sisko, Kirk, Kira

Data - because Q has a thing for him.

Guinan - because she has unspecified plot powers.

Quark - to "acquire" goods and services for the party.

Odo - to keep Quark from getting bored and selling our possessions while we sleep.

Miles - so I have someone who won't be traumatized by being constantly thrown to the wolves, both figuratively and literally.

Not sure why no one is mentioning Garak. Seems like a no brainer

I am not playing dnd with Q. Dont get me wrong, id love to meet Q and hang. And his abilities could make for the best dnd experince ever, but Q is such a prick. I cant imagine hed host a good session.

Generally speaking tho,

My physical stat character is Worf.

My caster is Troi.

My trap disarmer and general know it all is LaForge.

My cleric is Dr. Crusher.

My overpowered does it all better than all of them character is Data.

Ill give you one guess as to which series I grew up watching.

This brings up a mental game I've played of trying to decide which Star Trek characters would be the best tabletop DMs.

Here's my TNG list:

For the record, I think although TNG-era Worf would not be a great DM because he'd be so focused on combat that you'd get the impression he'd rather be playing 40k instead, by the time he reached his DS9 era, he'd have picked up a lot more openness to narrative and be much better.

Also, I think early season Wesley would actually be better than Starfleet Cadet Wesley, as he'd show a ton of promise and enthusiasm at first, but seems to become fairly insufferable by the time he's a cadet.

Ortegas (rogue), Ransom (~~barbarian~~warrior), Phlox (cleric), Spock (paladin), Geordi (wizard), Odo (druid), Vic (bard)

Oath of Glory Paladin - Worf

war Cleric - EMH/ECH

Thief Rogue - Quark

Divination Wizard - Wesley

Armorer Artificer - O’Brien

Sword bard/face - Okona

Barbarian/Guardian: Worf
Cleric: McCoy
Warlock/Oracle: Ezri Dax
Paladin (Oath of Redemption)/Investigator: Liam Shaw

I think that would he a good mix of characterisation to classes (DND and pathfinder)

Geordi for his smarts. Worf in case of combat, 3 redshirts. You know why.

• Data: utterly OP, can't not take Data
• Troi: always helpful when people are involved
• Riker: good leadership while being more physically capable than most captains, bold enough to endanger himself and his crew if necessary but smart enough to avoid it if not
• Bashir: Can handle any medical emergencies and, again, highly physically capable compared to other medical experts

Q as DM is a wash as far as I'm concerned: they're the same picture.

With that out of the way, this could go a bunch of different ways, but here's my most OP squad:

• Pike
• Riker
• Data
• Scotty
• EMH
• Worf

... and my most dysfunctional squad:

• Shaw
• Beckett
• B-4
• Tilly
• T'Ana
• Reed

Edit: if anyone is looking for a lightweight RPG framework to get this kind of thing moving fast, may I recommend "lasers and feelings.". The rules are just one page.

Give me the 5 leads from Lower Decks + S.A.M as the cadet

A handful of bards. Max charisma in the party. I'll put

• Neelix
• Quark
• Wesley Crusher
• Derek
• one of the ladies from the Risa resort