It's weird to use a slightly-better functioning version of that site again, and the whole "login to one server and get access to all" makes it significantly simpler than I thought it would be

The biggest thing that's surprised me is just how long the network has been around. I signed up for Identica (StatusNet platform, which became GNU Social) in 2008! The fediverse has only continued to grow and evolve. It's absolutely wild.

I think the concept of the Fediverse working that well is still sureal. It is so fascinating how a entirely community driven project works better then what some comapanys do. This is what Social Media should be. A place by Humans for Humans owned by everyone. Not some Company that just wants to make money.

How much better it is at being Reddit than Reddit. It feels like its the logical conclusion of what Reddit initially succeeded at for the user, before the perspective shifted towards myopic monetization.

I like the new location, due to the principle of federation itself. It's interesting to see how theaet many smaller communities will evolve, especially those of identical interests on different instances. There's an inherent messiness to the situation as we're mostly humans, so all the "baggage" I wish would stay on Reddit is someone else's entire enjoyment here...

I've also been surprised how many people are eagerly becoming moderators -- there are many communities I'd like to see, but am not convinced I could even moderate effectively, so it's impressive.

That said, I worry some of the excitement is due to novelty and self-convincing, like when people say "This is fun, right?" But maybe I'm just a bit too skeptical. Regardless, I'm enjoying the ride thusfar, and love seeing people's effort on instances, communities, apps be celebrated. It helps convince me that humans do enjoy cooperative success.

being able to connect to not only another instance, but also another platform. I can use my Mastodon account to follow a Pixelfed account and to reply to a Lemmy thread. that's not something that the mainstream, commercialized internet with its walled-off silos would ever let you do.

Seeing the same sorts of growing pains that other important Internet services have gone through. Yes, there's friction. It turns out, that's normal. It's probably going to keep happening. History doesn't repeat itself, but it sure does rhyme.

to me, it was surprising just how easy the fediverse was to understand if i stopped trying to think about it how i was taught to think by centralized platforms.

at first, i was really hesitant to migrate. i was confused by kbin, lemmy, mastodon, and especially the fediverse. i didn't think i could ever understand it. i wasn't confident in it. but, after a few hours of exploring, interacting, watching people talk about it and reading explanations, it clicked into place and suddenly made sense, a whole lotta sense. now, i am actually teaching others about what the fediverse is with little to no trouble and helping them migrate to kbin from reddit, and thats amazing. having tons of fun here! 👍

We need polished mobile apps to really push the fediverse to the masses. It has been a great experience so far though and I think I'll stay a while.

The two biggest surprises I've had so far:

1. Lack of federated login / single sign on. It seems bizarre in a land of federated instances to not have the identity provider decoupled (or even truly decentralized). Instance goes away? Poof, there goes your identity. "Backed up" your data and want to import it into another instance? That functionality doesn't exist today. And even if it were added, how do you validate?

I hate to even suggest it just because of how much of a buzzword it has become. But blockchain feels like a possible answer to the identity problem. It would couple one's identity to the network as opposed to the instance.

That's not to say that instance-level identities shouldn't be allowed as well; but it would be nice to have the option. Right now one basically needs to sign up for separate accounts on as many instances as possible to prevent bad actors from posing as them. A universal ID would solve that.

2. Lack of historical data. Are you the first subscriber to !bobswidgets@feder.icio.us through lemmy.world? Doesn't matter if the original community had fiftyleven posts. You only get to see any created after you subscribe?

Fediverse has taught me that social media can be decentralised.

Instead of stuck in a platform, Vulcan can read, write, and react to something posted in another instance (for example, from kbin to Lemmy).

BookWyrm. I'd searched intensively for a replacement for GoodReads, and been stuck with LibraryThing despite it's extreme user-hostility (by which I mean the opposite of user-friendliness, not that the people there were hostile). BookWyrm was what I was looking for all along!

I haven't found the porn I like yet