85
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 27 Nov 2023
85 points (100.0% liked)
Sydney
927 readers
13 users here now
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
A max fine of $3000 -$6000 per tree! That's tiny. Tree law in the US is brutal. If you illegally cut down a tree you owe the amount it would cost to have a tree of that type and size replanted there (those didn't look like small trees). If the tree is too big to feasibly replant an equivalent one there then generally you owe $2000 per year that tree had been growing. So if you cut down someones 100 year old tree then you owe them $200,000. Although the exact numbers may be changed now because I haven't had to look it up in a while.
With something like this someone needs to be bankrupted over it. A couple million dollars to a big developer is nothing. With something like this they should literally have to pay to replace all of those trees with identical ones plus punitive fines. Also how did noone see who did it? That's a pretty big landscaping effort for nobody to have seen anything. They also had to have taken the trees somewhere. There's no way that nobody saw anything. No traffic cams saw trucks carting 300 trees out of the area?
things_america_did_right += 1
Diggin ourselves out of the negatives one tree law at a time.
My state has treble damages for timber theft. Three times the value of the tree.
Yup. There's a reason that "forensic arborist" is an actual job title. Trees are worth way more than most people think.
My dad was a groundskeeper at a smallish local college that is somewhat known for its fairly large and diverse collection of trees. Nothing really exotic, just a wide variety of fairly normal trees that grow well in our climate. At one point a big landscaping company convinced someone on the college admin team to switch pesticides to their newer "green" pesticide. Well they went and treated a bunch of trees with this new pesticide and it wound up killing quite a few of the trees (probably not more than 20-25). The college wound up being awarded several $million in damages. US tree law is no joke.