112
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 09 Oct 2023
112 points (100.0% liked)
Perth / Western Australia
502 readers
14 users here now
Below are some resources for Perth/Western Australian info that could help find the perfect story for that exceptional post.
Suggestions to add to the list are very welcome!
This community wishes to be about all things Perth/WA, not just latest news. Whether its memes, dreams, or custard creams! Tell us your Western Australian story! 🦘
Local News/Lifestyle
The Urban List
University, TAFE and Related
Notre Dame
Miscellaneous
Brendan's Odyssey
Government/LGA
WA.Gov, announcements
Department of Biodiversity, Conservation, and Attractions
WA Podcasts
Wild WA Podcast
Occasional WA Focus
Renew Economy
ABC WA
ABC WA
founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
Idiots. Fucking idiots.
It's great that they want to take action on climate change but it's daft to think that these sorts of actions are going to achieve anything at all.
What were they actually planning to do? Throw some paint balloons and someone lock themselves to a gate and "say something profound" ?!
Even if they dissuaded whoever from doing whatever, woodside would just appoint someone else to do it?
Gerard the strategy guy should be relegated to handing out the kombucha .
When they glued themselves to the streets it was broadly criticized that the protesters were not targeting the ones responsible for climate change. That was already bs because people who choose a car for mobility are responsible for a part of climate change. Now when they are protesting against people who are even more responsible, like in this case, people like you criticize them for that. It seems like you would prefer if they would not protest at all.
I'm criticising them for being completely ineffective. Worse than that even - counter productive, because they undermine effective climate change activism.
Please describe what is effective climate change activism in your opinion, because I am unsure what you mean by that.
Effective climate change activism would mitigate climate change in some way.
These guys achieved absolutely nothing.
Are you able to explain what the objective was?
How many books have you read on political theory?
Who are your favorite critics of peoples movements and the history of protest politics?
This is an open question to all.
I have read 4-5 books on political theory, most of them on Marxism and various sects of anarchal socialism. Probably two dozen journal articles.
My favourite author is some guy out of a French university who published on contemporary civil disobedience a couple of years ago. And I certainly like the classics; Thoreau, Gandhi and ML King.
My favourite critic of nonviolent protest is Fred Hampton.
Amazing.
Lol troll
Sorry mate it's just a weird thing to say.
In anonymous online forums stating your credentials doesn't have the intended effect.
You're a troll and you have no intent in engaging in good faith argument
Don´t let the guy bother you. The best way to deal with trolls is to block them.
Sure mate. It's much easier to conclude that everyone you disagree with is a troll rather than acknowledging valid criticisms.
No one has been able to offer any insights into what the individuals featured in the article intended to achieve. Your ghandi quote refers to "tension" yet this protest was completely unsuccessful in achieving that.
The assertion that nothing was achieved here is the "good faith argument".
Can you give an example? what activism would mitigate climate change?
Yes. Can you?
Just like you mitigate answering my question, troll -> blocked
Ah yes, the hallmark of enlightened debate: block people that ask uncomfortable questions.
No one has answered my simple question: what were these people hoping to achieve?
You are talking about them. Seems quite effective.
Well "talking about" yes - but are these people really our best ambassadors? They can't be our best and brightest surely.
So we should patiently wait for things to change by voting every few years?
Protests are what changed the world for the better.
We need nukes
You totally had me until you got offensive. Just like DogMuffins comment getting offensive is also not particularly constructive you know.
I totally had you? Like I'm some tricksky little hobbitses that almost made you think taters was nice until I said a mean thing too?
Their using offensive words wasn't my main problem with their post, it was the suppressive dismissal of protestors, so you pointing out my hypocrisy of also being a meanypants doesn't really bother me. The planet is dying, they're mad that people are mad, and you're mad I didn't say "that's a ridiculous position" in a nice enough way? K.
Did you even read my comment to DogMuffins post? https://lemmy.world/comment/4341772
No not at all, I am mad (depressed would be more precise) about climate change as well and I do agree with you, except for the small offensive part at the end. I think I communicated that pretty clearly and you somehow misunderstood. You should calm down a little, I am not your enemy. I understand how angry you are because I was extremely angry too until being depressed about it became dominant. I just think that the tone people use on lemmy matters and I don´t like the toxic reddit style tone I am seeing here, that´s all.
I'm sorry you're feeling depressed, really. It can be depressing, what's happening globaly. Your feelings are valid considering the circumstances, but I'm sorry they're causing you pain. I hope you feel a sense of peace and renew your fighting spirit for Earth. I didn't mean to mischaracterise which negative emotion you felt about the tone of my post, I should have been less specific when I said "mad". Sorry for that.
I do agree that tone is important, and my tone could have been better, you're right. In fact, I've been warned I violated rule 2 in private by a mod. I've promised to try to do better. Hopefully this comment has kept to that promise but I'll abide by whatever the mods decide.
Tone is important, but content of the message is, in my opinion, more important than the tone. I don't think you're my enemy, I just think you're letting the decor distract from the architecture and engineering.
I´m happy we manged to turn this around. I wish you all the best!
Sure mate.
Holding in a fart just now has achieved more than these nimrods.
What a thoughtful response. I really appreciate how you offered multiple points in which the protestors could improve their messaging. Your insightful critique is sure to bring success in combating man made climate change. Thank you for your help! ( Was that friendly enough, NakedMole?)
Oh yes, well done! I wish I could upvote more than once and I am very proud of you! /s
Seriously though - I asked the guy two hours ago
The question was ignored, so the guy really seems to be just a troll unworthy of a discussion. I propose we just ignore him from now on.
Spoken like someone who is afraid to even try
Who is this quote from? Whoever they are, they put their case very well.
Gandhi
Wow. I think i'll need to pay more attention to what he taught
Eh, he was also kinda creepy in some of his stuff too. As with everything, take the good, drop the bad.
My whole point, is that the "activists" in question were completely unsuccessful in creating any "tension" whatsoever.