I get what you're saying, but I think the strong objection is that implementing this now, right when these BS laws are being put into place, goes against one of the fundamental principles that Linux is built on. And doing this is a willful action toward capitulating to Big Brother - because we all know this doesn't stop with just put your b-day in and we will just trust you. This is a stepping stone toward more and more control and verified ID. Any part of the Linux community that does not openly defy this and stand against it will invariably be looked at as traitorous and collaborator. And if you take a moment and think about what this community stands for (yes, there's a philosophy it's not just software; there are very distinct ethical principles represented by Linux, regardless whether you dismiss this or not), it's clear that this adding of the field now, to accommodate this Big Brother shit, is dispicable in the extreme.