228
Bernie Sanders becomes first US senator to say Israel committing genocide in Gaza
(www.theguardian.com)
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
view the rest of the comments
this post was submitted on 17 Sep 2025
228 points (100.0% liked)
Palestine
2134 readers
211 users here now
A community to discuss everything Palestine.
Rules:
-
Posts can be in Arabic or English.
-
Please add a flair in the title of every post. Example: “[News] Israel annexes the West Bank ”, “[Culture] Musakhan is the nicest food in the world!”, “[Question] How many Palestinians live in Jordan?”
List of flairs: [News] [Culture] [Discussion] [Question] [Request] [Guide]
founded 5 years ago
MODERATORS
Plenty of people correctly said it was a genocide since 1948, so I'm not sure what you mean here.
Ditto.
I don't disagree with the points I made, but they were made insensitively in an inappropriate space, and I am removing them
Forced displacement and ethnic cleansing isn't genocide??
Performing genocide denial and erasing the Nakba to show why genocide has only just occurred is weird.
Again, best to remove this
You said the bar for genocide has only just been reached in 2025.... erasing the Nakba that started in 1947.
Being rude AND denying a genocide won't get you anywhere, pick a struggle.
It is not my advice and I would never speak on behalf of the Palestinians, so maybe get that clear.
Absolutely love that the part of my post that it presumably got deleted for is visible in your comment about it. That says something, doesn't it?
Yes, that we were correct you were rude with that comment. Quoting the part where you were rude is not necessarily a breach of the rules.
Good stuff, hope you find this a productive way of engaging yourself in discussion. Would hate for you to have to see a rude word (that you hadn't yourself posted, Obviously. You're special and get special rules because you're so great and we all love you)
What a fucking baby
Quite
Accepting that something is a genocide and stressing that genocide is bad but also other genocides exist doesn't sound like denial to me but you do you
The nakba was a genocide, dumbass. Don't blame others for your ignorance; you chose to be loud and wrong; then people smarter than you called that out.
Instead of calling people names you should do some research on the genocide and colonization of Palestinians/Palestine.
Ok numbers obviously not your strong suit. Displacement of 700k ppl, whilst obviously a tragedy on a massive scale, is not equatable to the murder of 8+ million. That is my claim. If you wish to dispute it plz tr harder than 'genocide denier', just because you happen to care more about this one.
I'm gonna spell it out nice and slow for you: the nakba was a genocide.
Calling it a "displacement" when it lead to the total ethnic removal of a group of people is actually trying to mislabel what everyone (except you) understands happened.
Genocides include: killing, rape, and displacement. All of which happened in the nakba. Genocide is when you want to remove people from a land by means of displacement and murder based entirely on the identity of the victims.
People get displaced due to wars and natural disasters; we don't call those genocides because there is no fucking desire to destroy/remove an entire group of people based on their identity.
Genocide= people are being killed and removed because of their race/religion/ethnicity
I cannot explain it any simpler, if you still don't understand then you're either stupid, rotten, or some combination of the two.
Mate. The point I'm here to make is : calling what's happening in Palestine the worst genocide since the Holocaust of the Jewish people is not a strictly accurate claim by most metric I would expect to measure it by (total death count or proportion of population being the two most obvious ones, hence Cambodia because that was fuckinc rough). Will it eventually achieve that notorious level of savagery? I hope not. I hope the cunts are shamed into behaving. But it behoovs you you remember that there are many many terrible things going on and which have already gone on, and some sweeping statements with no basis in anything quantitative can look very much like erasure.
Of course you're already know this because you're super duper smart and awesome and just such a font of moral wisdom, there are never any grey spaces with you, it's amazing the clarity that comes to me in those brief moments where you're here to help guide me
Sorry, I misspoke in my passion. I meant to say a quarter of 8 million people. I apologise for the misleading numbers
Then say "2 million" you fucking dumbass, who tf says "a quarter of 8 million"?
Someone referring to the fact that it was a quarter of the population of a country with 8mil ppl living in it. Dumbass.
Then say 2 fucking million. Everyone can do the math and no one dick measures genocides with percents.
Jesus, admit you're wrong and fuck off.
That's Cambodia I'm talking about btw. It's one of the other genocides. Of which there are far too many to be remotely comfortable. One is evil incarnate. Do not think for a second I am trying to make excuses.