Biblical plothole? (Adam and Eve v. Good and Evil) (self.atheism)

submitted 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago) by uriel238 to c/atheism@lemmy.world

34 comments fedilink hide all child comments

Refrigerator logic, or a shower thought:

According to Genesis, God forbids Adam and Eve from eating fruit of the tree of wisdom, specifically of knowledge of good and evil.

Serpent talks to Eve, calling out God's lie: God said they will die from eating the fruit (as in die quickly, as if the fruit were poisonous). They won't die from the fruit, Serpent tells them. Instead, their eyes will open and they will understand good and evil.

And Adam and Eve eat of the fruit of the tree of wisdom, learning good and evil (right and wrong, or social mores). And then God evicts them from paradise for disobedience.

But if the eating the fruit of the tree of wisdom gave Adam and Eve the knowledge of good and evil, this belies they did not know good and evil in the first place. They couldn't know what forbidden means, or that eating from the tree was wrong. They were incapable of obedience.

Adam and Eve were too unintelligent (immature? unwise?) to understand, much like telling a toddler not to eat cookies from the cookie jar on the counter.

Putting the tree unguarded and easily accessible in the Garden of Eden was totally a setup

Am I reading this right?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments

[-] lvxferre@mander.xyz 25 points 2 months ago

I think that you are reading it right. And while I personally wouldn't associate obedience with moral "good", whoever wrote this myth clearly did.

In fact the whole myth feels like Yahweh creating a successful trap for the couple - the tree is in the garden, but they aren't supposed to eat from it; the snake was in the garden, but they weren't supposed to listen to it; and the serpent speaking the truth while Yahweh was being a liar ("you'll die"... except they didn't.)

[+] fishpen0@lemmy.world 9 points 2 months ago

[deleted]

[-] uriel238 3 points 2 months ago

Dan McClellen actually released a video today regarding this specific matter. ( on YouTube )

[-] lvxferre@mander.xyz 1 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

Thank you for sharing this video - what he says about the paronomastic infinitive is interesting, and it explains an oddity of the same verse in the Vulgate:

Gen 2:17 de ligno autem scientiae boni et mali ne comedas in quocumque enim die comederis ex eo morte morieris

"Morte morieris" is literally "you'll die of death". The expression sounds as weird and redundant in Latin as it does in English - but it makes sense if Jerome of Stridon was trying to reproduce a Hebrew figure of speech.

(Interestingly enough, "die" [in the day] is also there. And that "ex eo" ["out of that", i.e. as a consequence] also reinforces that Adam would die as a consequence of eating from the tree.)

[-] lvxferre@mander.xyz 1 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

Following that interpretation, what Yahweh said is a half-truth - because it implies that the fruit itself would cause their death, when it doesn't. They would eventually die because Yahweh would revoke their immortality, but the fruit itself does what Serpent said that it would, granting them knowledge.

In the Sumerian story of the gardens of Dilmun, Enki and Ninhursanga, Enki eats of the eight forbidden plants so as to gain knowledge of them

Great catch - I completely forgot about this myth. I've seen a different, but still related version, might as well explore it here:

Enki sleeps with Ninhursag, they have Ninšar.
Then with Ninšar, they have Ninkurra. ~~As they do it Sweet Home Alabama plays in the background.~~
Then with Ninkurra, and they have Uttu.
Then, as Enki sleeps with Uttu, Ninhursag removes Enki's semen from Uttu's body and throws on the ground, creating the eight plants that you mentioned.
Isimud (Enki's assistant) uproots those plants and give them to Enki, who eats them - so now he knows the heart and determines the destiny of each plant.
Ninhursag gets pissed and then curses Enki, withdrawing her "life-giving eye" from him, so he falls sick.

Ninhursag governs over the mountains, while the other three goddesses govern human activities (Ninšar and meat cooking, Ninkurra and sculpting, Uttu and weaving). And the later was probably not considered as important as the others, due to the absence of the prefix Nin- "Lady, Mistress".

As such, Ninhursag likely governed over wild plants too, like the ones that Enki ate; and, once Enki to control those plants, he was invading her realm. Or, alternatively, by knowing better those plants Enki had a reason to control the mountains, instead of sticking to the wetlands.

Either way, if the Hebrew myth of Adam and Eve was influenced by this one, suddenly it makes sense why Yahweh punishes Adam and Eve - Yahweh's realm would be morality, and the couple invaded it.

[-] AngryCommieKender@lemmy.world 2 points 2 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago)

I'm beginning to believe, but can't prove that all these creation garden myths are talking about The Green Sahara, and it's subsequent desertification. Again I can't prove it, but the end of the green Sahara seems to line up with, and may have even caused, The Bronze Age Collapse. I'll bet that those two back to back events convinced people that the world was legitimately ending.

[-] lvxferre@mander.xyz 2 points 2 months ago

It's possible; the peak of the Green Sahara period was ~8000 BCE, while the Epic of Gilgamesh is from 2100 BCE. As the desertification of the Sahara and Levant went on, it's possible that small pockets of greenery remained for longer, becoming the target of oral traditions, that eventually the Epic and other myths borrowed from.

I just find a bit unlikely because those myths typically have something to do with humans or human-like gods doing something and, as a consequence, either spoiling or leaving the garden:

Hebrew - humans develop morality, so they're kicked out
Sumerian - humans distance themselves from nature, as they try to wrestle control over it (that's how I interpret it at least - the man vs. nature theme is common in Sumerian myths).
Ugarit tablets - god El has a tree of life, god Horon transforms it into a tree of death

Then in the Greek myth I don't think that they give the garden of the Hesperides some end or similar. It's simply there.

this post was submitted on 04 Oct 2024

47 points (100.0% liked)

Atheism

4115 readers

1 users here now

Community Guide

Archive Today will help you look at paywalled content the way search engines see it.

Statement of Purpose

This is a support and conversation community for people who don't believe in gods.
Superstition hucksters have no reason to subscribe or post here at all.
If you are looking to debate or proselytize, options will be linked lower in the sidebar.

Acceptable

Honest questions or conversations.
Discussions on parenting or advice.
Struggles, frustrations, coming out.
Atheist memes. We can have fun!
News headlines relevant to atheism.

Unacceptable

Depending on severity, you might be warned before adverse action is taken.

Anything against site rules.
Illegal and/or NSFW material.
Troll posts and comments. There will be no attempt to explain what that means.
Leading questions, agenda pushing, or disingenuous attempts to bait members.
Personal attacks or flaming.

Inadvisable

Self promotion or upvote farming.
Excessive shitposting or off-topic discussion.

Application of warnings or bans will be subject to moderator discretion. Feel free to appeal. If changes to the guidelines are necessary, they will be adjusted.

If you vocally harass or discriminate against any individual member, you will be removed.

Likewise, if you are a member, sympathizer or a resemblant of a group that is known to largely hate, mock, discriminate against, and/or want to take lives of any other group of people, and you were provably vocal about your hate, then you you will be banned on sight.

Provable means able to provide proof to the moderation, and, if necessary, to the community.

 ~ /c/nostupidquestions

If you want your space listed in this sidebar and it is especially relevant to the atheist or skeptic communities, PM DancingPickle and we'll have a look!

Connect with Atheists

Matrix: #atheism:envs.net

Help and Support Links

Streaming Media

This is mostly YouTube at the moment. Podcasts and similar media - especially on federated platforms - may also feature here.

Orgs, Blogs, Zines

Mainstream

Bibliography

Start here...

...proceed here.

Proselytize Religion

Convince an Atheist

From Reddit

As a community with an interest in providing the best resources to its members, the following wiki links are provided as historical reference until we can establish our own.

founded 2 years ago

MODERATORS

Rhynoplaz@lemmy.world