My take;

1/3rd of the US people are allies to Canada. 1/3rd of the US people are neutral or don't care about Canada.

The concern though is 1/3 of the people (MAGA) and the government are hostile enemies of Canada. Because of this, Canada needs to consider all of the US as an enemy country. Or at best a county we can not trust at all.

The US is requiring Canadians allow border guards access to their social media when crossing the border. There are reports of them turning away those who are against Trump. Canada should require the same of Americans.

Trump constantly threatens Canada's well being, safety and sovereignty. He directly desires to hurt us with his illegal trade war. We need to take this seriously.

Canada should screen Americans at the border for which party they support. If they support Trump, they should be banned permanently from entering the country. These are enemies of Canada.

Republicans: Enemy

Everyone else: Ally

Until the current regime is ousted, the supremists neatly packaged and sent away, and democracy under the constitution restored, why pick just Canada? We aren't the "good guys" right now. We're a worldwide worry, we're Russia's mini-me. 🤷

The current U.S. administration is outright hostile to pretend otherwise is dangerous. Sure, the president borrows from Vladimir Putin’s playbook, undermining us with soft power projection. But that shouldn’t downplay the severity of the threat.

Between the constant "51st state" rhetoric, repeated tariff threats, and strong-arming us into footing the bill for contracts that’ll inevitably funnel money back into his/their pockets, anyone who doesn’t see this as dangerously aggressive is delusional.

maple maga might support him, but what is there to decide?

The relationship between Canada and its southern neighbor has seemed a little too good to be true for a long time. A cynic might be inclined to believe that some amount of effort, from one or both States, has been put into crafting that image of harmonic cooperation in hopes that the illusion will become real.

It sure didn't take much to fuck that whole plan up.