Going from left to right it looks like he spent nine years drinking the world's oceans and has since moved on to consuming the planet itself.

I honestly like 2004 the best. I could see the issue with it then when resolutions were lower, but I feel like we could go back to it now. It looks so much nicer, though arguably less recognizable at a glance from across the room or something.

I will also go with 2013.

2009 one is by far my fave. I love that 3D look compared to the flat minimalistic look the 2017 and 2019 versions have

im torn between old design and new frankly. I really like the little details present in the old logo, but not the explicit 3d nature of them. I much prefer the flat styling of modern applications, it's just more suited to functionality IMO.

Bring the modern one some more detail, give it a paw, make the globe blue, i'll be happy.