87
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[-] Samskara@sh.itjust.works 1 points 1 day ago

AI-assisted

I have followed this topic since the 1990s and I’m capable of writing more than two sentences on this topic.

to create division among Palestinians

Yes, Israel exploited the division of Palestinians at times. The division itself and the failure to resolve it is fully the work of Palestinians.

supremacist Zionist government treats Palestinians with the same contempt that Nazis treated Jews

You are either misinformed about what’s happening in Israel/Palestine or how the Nazis treated the Jews, likely both. It’s nowhere even similar. Nazi Germany took away citizenship of all Jews, removed them from public office, state jobs, universities. Jews had to wear a Star of David on their clothing. 20% of Israeli citizens are Arab Palestinians with full rights. Israeli Arabs work in all professions from university professors to judges at courts. This is very different from Nazi death camps.

The Nazi comparisons only serve the antisemitic goal of retroactively legitimizing the Holocaust. They are devoid of any factual basis.

Comparisons to Turkey or the USA would be more accurate, if you want to find parallels.

me, could you coexist and prosper with a neighbour who had thrown you out of your own home, trashed it and treats you with evil cruelty? Don't you think that neighbour would have to give you your home back, pay you for the damage done and admit their actions were wrong before you could live side by side amicably.

My own ancestors were forcibly displaced from Danzig and lost everything they owned. They themselves accepted at some point that it was lost forever. I don’t blow up buses in Poland in the hope of getting my ancestors‘ house back.

The same is true for many millions all over Europe and elsewhere (India-Pakistan split, Turkey/Greece, Ukraine/Poland) that were displaced in the 1940s. The vast majority accepted the loss and live peacefully with their neighbors today.

800,000 Jews were expelled from Arab and Muslim countries from the 1940s onwards. They also lost property.

Wars, refugees, displacement happen usually involving loss of property. Compensation is rare.

That said, I think some kind of compensation for Palestinians should be part of a peace deal.

How do you feel about the Jews living in Jerusalem, that were forced out by Jordan in 1948? They lost their houses as well. East Jerusalem used to be majority Jewish at the time. Jordan then moved other people into these houses. After Israel annexed Jerusalem, some of the original owners tried to win back their lost property through the courts. Some were successful and get paid rent by the new inhabitants. Others want to move into these houses themselves, but evicting the tenants isn’t always easy. That’s what’s happening in Sheik Jarrah in Jerusalem.

[-] arbilp3@aussie.zone 1 points 1 day ago

Not convincing. Read, if you like, this report which is just one of many we can find online on the situation of Israeli Arabs and which is not written by any Palestinian organisation which you might consider biased: https://www.cfr.org/backgrounders/what-know-about-arab-citizens-israel

[-] Samskara@sh.itjust.works 1 points 1 day ago

Your link agrees with me.

Arabs have sat on the Supreme Court and worked in the foreign service, with a handful serving as ambassadors since 1995. Many have served as mayors, judges in lower courts, and in civil service positions.

Sure there is some discrimination against Israeli Arabs. It’s nothing like Nazi Germany though. It’s much more similar to minorities being discriminated and disadvantaged in the USA.

The situation for Palestinians with resident status in East Jerusalem is obviously different because they aren’t citizens. Palestinian residents of Jerusalem were able to apply for citizenship for decades. Many didn’t do it for various reasons. An important issue was not be seen as a traitor other Palestinians.

Similar issues exist with Arab Israelis. They don’t have to serve in the army, but can voluntarily. Not serving has disadvantages because they aren’t making social connections during their service. As your article also mentions, many of them don’t vote even though they have the right. That is changing though. Yoseph Haddad is a great example of an Arab Israeli who decided to serve in the army and became a successful journalist later on. He’s now working on integrating Israeli Arabs more into the political system.

[-] arbilp3@aussie.zone 1 points 13 hours ago
this post was submitted on 17 Apr 2026
87 points (100.0% liked)

Overseas News

709 readers
1 users here now

A place for Australians and friends to share news from the other countries. Like all communities here, we discuss topics from the Australian perspective.

If you're looking for a global /c/worldnews instead, search for the many options on federated instances.

Rules
  1. Follow the aussie.zone rules
  2. We are not a generic World News clone. News must be relevant to Australians and our region. Obvious disregard will earn an warning and then a ban if continued. (If an article isn't from an Oceanian news outlet, and it doesn’t mention Australia, then it’s probably off-topic)
  3. Leave seppocentrism at the door. If you don't know what that means, you're not ready to post here yet.
  4. Avoid editorialising headlines. Opinions go in the comments, not the post.

founded 2 years ago
MODERATORS